Bitter truths and lies of Hasan Minhaj: American media's repackaging of Islamophobia? | The Business Standard
Skip to main content
  • Latest
  • Economy
    • Banking
    • Stocks
    • Industry
    • Analysis
    • Bazaar
    • RMG
    • Corporates
    • Aviation
  • Videos
    • TBS Today
    • TBS Stories
    • TBS World
    • News of the day
    • TBS Programs
    • Podcast
    • Editor's Pick
  • World+Biz
  • Features
    • Panorama
    • The Big Picture
    • Pursuit
    • Habitat
    • Thoughts
    • Splash
    • Mode
    • Tech
    • Explorer
    • Brands
    • In Focus
    • Book Review
    • Earth
    • Food
    • Luxury
    • Wheels
  • Subscribe
    • Epaper
    • GOVT. Ad
  • More
    • Sports
    • TBS Graduates
    • Bangladesh
    • Supplement
    • Infograph
    • Archive
    • Gallery
    • Long Read
    • Interviews
    • Offbeat
    • Magazine
    • Climate Change
    • Health
    • Cartoons
  • বাংলা
The Business Standard

Sunday
July 06, 2025

Sign In
Subscribe
  • Latest
  • Economy
    • Banking
    • Stocks
    • Industry
    • Analysis
    • Bazaar
    • RMG
    • Corporates
    • Aviation
  • Videos
    • TBS Today
    • TBS Stories
    • TBS World
    • News of the day
    • TBS Programs
    • Podcast
    • Editor's Pick
  • World+Biz
  • Features
    • Panorama
    • The Big Picture
    • Pursuit
    • Habitat
    • Thoughts
    • Splash
    • Mode
    • Tech
    • Explorer
    • Brands
    • In Focus
    • Book Review
    • Earth
    • Food
    • Luxury
    • Wheels
  • Subscribe
    • Epaper
    • GOVT. Ad
  • More
    • Sports
    • TBS Graduates
    • Bangladesh
    • Supplement
    • Infograph
    • Archive
    • Gallery
    • Long Read
    • Interviews
    • Offbeat
    • Magazine
    • Climate Change
    • Health
    • Cartoons
  • বাংলা
SUNDAY, JULY 06, 2025
Bitter truths and lies of Hasan Minhaj: American media's repackaging of Islamophobia?

Splash

Tasfia Tasneem
07 November, 2023, 04:45 pm
Last modified: 07 November, 2023, 05:06 pm

Related News

  • Punchlines, politics, and a risk that didn’t pay off
  • 'No more fear': Stand-up comedy returns to post-Assad Syria
  • Off With His Head: Is Hasan Minhaj afraid of his own jokes now?
  • Comedy Insurgency: Flew too high, crashed too hard
  • Pope Francis invites comedians including Whoopi Goldberg to Vatican

Bitter truths and lies of Hasan Minhaj: American media's repackaging of Islamophobia?

Tasfia Tasneem
07 November, 2023, 04:45 pm
Last modified: 07 November, 2023, 05:06 pm
Hasan Minhaj on his Netflix special 'The Kings Jester'.
Hasan Minhaj on his Netflix special 'The Kings Jester'.

On 15 September, an article in The New Yorker took social media by storm as it pointed fingers at comedian Hasan Minhaj.

In the article penned by Clare Malone, a white American who is an Ohio-native, she alleged that Minhaj had "fabricated" a series of personal events he recounted during his standup shows over the years.

Titled "Emotional Truths", the article would go on to contend that the stories Minhaj told on stage, which generated quite a few chuckles to say the least, were either exaggerated or outright untrue.

The Business Standard Google News Keep updated, follow The Business Standard's Google news channel

The New Yorker investigated some of the most impactful bits from his standup show that helped him connect to his audience on a deeper level.

The article was picked up by almost all media outlets, which went on to gleefully label Minhaj a "dishonest performer".

The article, for instance, cast doubt on the integrity of Minhaj's account of being stood up by his prom date, who happened to be a white girl.

It also raised skepticism regarding other details, like the one where an FBI informant purportedly attempted to entrap Minhaj and his associates at a mosque, and another incident several years later when he had to hastily rush his daughter to the hospital due to receiving an envelope containing white powder, which he suspected to be anthrax.

"The nature of storytelling, let alone comedic storytelling, is inventive," said the New Yorker. "Its primary aim is to make an impression, to amuse or to engage. But the stakes appear to change when entertainers fabricate anecdotes about current events and issues of social injustice."

The article opened up a hornet's nest.

In response, Hasan Minhaj uploaded a video on social media explaining his side of the story. And the truth behind his "emotional truths."

Minhaj said there was a distinction between his news-based shows, where "the truth comes first," and his stand-up performances, where "the emotional truth" takes precedence.

For instance, the prom incident did take place; it's just that he compressed the timeline to make it appear that he heard of his rejection while at the girl's doorstep.

From Hasan's point of view, changing the timeline added to the comedic value and impact of his stories that might have been impossible if presented as it was.

Hasan, in his video, revealed that the encounter with the FBI agent never happened, but he did have confrontations with undercover law enforcement during his upbringing.

Also, while the distressing letter did exist, he didn't rush his daughter to the hospital because he later discovered, upon opening it, that the contents were not real anthrax.

The artistic intent, as Minhaj explained, was to "recreate that sensation - one exclusive to Muslims - for a wide-ranging audience; the feeling of paranoia and vindication, tension and release."

The incidents he incorporated into his show might not all be his truth. Hasan, however, wanted to create an impact by telling the collective truth of an entire community. If he went on only telling stories of people in his community, the stand-up special might have been deprived of its value.

Understandably, it might be difficult for everyone to navigate between the different comedy segments.

Later, the New Yorker did respond to his video saying that Hasan did confirm their claims of fabricating his stories and that what they reported was correct.

Even though the New Yorker's reporting and fact-checking were done thoroughly, they seemed to completely misunderstand some of the impacts of the interview they had with the comedian or the point of his video.

Their confirmation does beg questions like, why was only Hasan Minhaj under such fact-checking when it's a common practice among comedians to change details? Why were they so focused on the timeline of his stories? And missing the point of the creative choices he took. How is it different from other forms of storytelling?

A number of comedians came out in support of Minhaj. After all, what he had done was not something new.

Comedy – especially stand-up – has always been used to reinforce home truths.

Dave Chappelle, for instance, used his platform to raise the profile of the Black struggle in White America.

His "sprinkle some crack on them" line spoke about entrapment, how law enforcers would kill black Americans and then frame it as a drug bust.

While the incident Chapelle recounted wasn't true, it was a snapshot of what was happening.

That America grapples with Islamophobia isn't something to debate. It's pretty much a fact, a fiery one where further fuel was added post-9/11. 

How does creative non-fiction work?

Minhaj's style of comedy can be described as creative non-fiction where the artist takes inspiration from real-life events and further dramatises or exaggerates. 

So, where should one draw the lines between exaggeration, fictional technique, and outright fabrication?

Clearly, the incidents under discussion shouldn't be entirely fabricated; there must be an initial basis from which the writer constructs a narrative.

"In my work as a storytelling comedian, I assumed that the lines between truth and fiction were allowed to be a bit more blurry," said Minhaj.

In this belief, as proven by countless other comedians, Minhaj is clearly in the right.

How a magazine the stature of the New Yorker could commission and print such a "hit piece" is one that needs further focus.

Why pick on Minhaj? Are his exaggerations too real for the comfort of White America?

Isn't it the same as when White America declared war against hip-hop – a genre populated by Black artists – for bringing in stories from the "hood", tales rife with instances of discrimination and police brutality?

For now, Clare Malone and the New Yorker stand by their article. After all, their investigation of a fictional show proved it was fictional.

Nothing wrong with that.

The problem, however, still lies with the White gaze, still gripped by an Islamophobic frenzy. And the attempt to erase the struggles of an entire community because it may not be convenient to America's hyper-liberal, democratic dream.

Top News

Hasan Minhaj / Comedian / Standup Comedy Show

Comments

While most comments will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive, moderation decisions are subjective. Published comments are readers’ own views and The Business Standard does not endorse any of the readers’ comments.

Top Stories

  • Infographic: TBS
    Japanese loan rate hits record 2%, still remains cheaper than others
  • Photo: Collected
    Jamaat presses ahead with candidate rollout, announces aspirants for 293 JS seats
  • A quieter scene at Dhaka University’s central library on 29 June, with seats still unfilled—unlike earlier this year, when the space was overwhelmed by crowds of job aspirants preparing for competitive exams. Photo: Tahmidul Alam Jaeef
    No more long queues at DU Central Library. What changed?

MOST VIEWED

  • The release was jointly carried out by the Forest Department and the Chattogram Zoo authorities as part of an ongoing initiative to conserve wildlife and maintain ecological balance. Photo: Collected
    33 Python hatchlings born in Ctg zoo released into Hazarikhil sanctuary
  • File photo of a new NBR office in Agargaon, Dhaka. Photo: UNB
    NBR launches 'a-Chalan' for instant online tax payments
  • Customs bureaucracy: Luxury cars rot at Ctg port
    Customs bureaucracy: Luxury cars rot at Ctg port
  • Infograph: TBS
    How BB’s floating rate regime calms forex market
  • Finance Adviser Salehuddin Ahmed talks to reporters in Brahmanbaria on Saturday, 5 July 2025. Photo: TBS
    Raising savings certificate interest rates will hurt banks: Finance adviser
  • Saleudh Zaman
    ‘We are dying’: Adverse policies drive most textile millers to edge, say industry leaders

Related News

  • Punchlines, politics, and a risk that didn’t pay off
  • 'No more fear': Stand-up comedy returns to post-Assad Syria
  • Off With His Head: Is Hasan Minhaj afraid of his own jokes now?
  • Comedy Insurgency: Flew too high, crashed too hard
  • Pope Francis invites comedians including Whoopi Goldberg to Vatican

Features

Students of different institutions protest demanding the reinstatement of the 2018 circular cancelling quotas in recruitment in government jobs. Photo: Mehedi Hasan

5 July 2024: Students announce class boycott amid growing protests

1d | Panorama
Contrary to long-held assumptions, Gen Z isn’t politically clueless — they understand both local and global politics well. Photo: TBS

A misreading of Gen Z’s ‘political disconnect’ set the stage for Hasina’s ouster

1d | Panorama
Graphics: TBS

How courier failures are undermining Bangladesh’s online perishables trade

1d | Panorama
The July Uprising saw people from all walks of life find themselves redrawing their relationship with politics. Photo: Mehedi Hasan

Red July: The political awakening of our urban middle class

2d | Panorama

More Videos from TBS

After backing Israel, Iran’s self-styled crown prince loses support

After backing Israel, Iran’s self-styled crown prince loses support

3h | TBS World
Trump says he is about to raise tariffs as high as 70% on some countries

Trump says he is about to raise tariffs as high as 70% on some countries

14h | TBS World
Will political disputes delay the elections?

Will political disputes delay the elections?

15h | TBS Stories
Initiative to break the deadlock created by the US

Initiative to break the deadlock created by the US

15h | TBS World
EMAIL US
contact@tbsnews.net
FOLLOW US
WHATSAPP
+880 1847416158
The Business Standard
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Sitemap
  • Advertisement
  • Privacy Policy
  • Comment Policy
Copyright © 2025
The Business Standard All rights reserved
Technical Partner: RSI Lab

Contact Us

The Business Standard

Main Office -4/A, Eskaton Garden, Dhaka- 1000

Phone: +8801847 416158 - 59

Send Opinion articles to - oped.tbs@gmail.com

For advertisement- sales@tbsnews.net