How Andrew's royal downfall deepens latest crisis for Britain's monarchy
The 1997 death of Princess Diana, Charles' ex-wife, became another defining moment as her fatal car crash in Paris at age 36 stunned the world and exposed a rift between public mourning and the royal family's private silence
Britain's monarchy, long shaped by its sensitivity to public opinion, is once again facing turbulence following the downfall of Prince Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor.
King Charles III on Thursday (30 October) stripped his younger brother of both his princely title and his official residence, marking the monarch's strongest effort yet to distance the royal family from Andrew's links to the late convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein.
The move follows years of damaging scandals involving Andrew and reflects Charles' attempt to protect the institution from further controversy. Epstein, who died by suicide in 2019 while awaiting trial on sex trafficking charges, had been convicted more than a decade earlier.
Keep updated, follow The Business Standard's Google news channel
The British monarchy — officially known as the House of Windsor — has survived multiple crises over the past century that have tested its endurance and public legitimacy.
Wartime backlash
According to George Gross, a royal historian at King's College London, the last comparable precedent to Andrew's removal dates back to World War I. The 1917 Titles Deprivation Act allowed Britain to revoke titles from royals who had sided with Germany.
The royal family's German roots ran deep through Queen Victoria's marriage to Prince Albert of Saxe-Coburg and Gotha. When war broke out in 1914, members of the extended royal family found themselves on opposite sides.
In 1917, King George V renamed his lineage the House of Windsor and removed titles from nobles deemed enemies of Britain, including Prince Ernest Augustus, duke of Cumberland and Teviotdale. According to the House of Commons Library, it remains the only instance of such a measure in modern history.
The abdication crisis
A similar constitutional shock came in 1936 when King Edward VIII gave up the throne to marry American divorcee Wallis Simpson. At the time, the Church of England barred remarriage after divorce, making the union politically and religiously untenable.
Edward abdicated that December, saying in a radio address he could not continue "without the help and support of the woman I love". His decision forced a redefinition of royal duty and ushered in a new era of service and restraint under his brother, King George VI — later inherited by Queen Elizabeth II and now King Charles III.
Edward and Wallis, later titled the Duke and Duchess of Windsor, spent most of their lives abroad amid suspicion of Nazi sympathies.
Diana's death
The 1997 death of Princess Diana, Charles' ex-wife, became another defining moment. Her fatal car crash in Paris at age 36 stunned the world and exposed a rift between public mourning and the royal family's private silence.
As crowds gathered and tributes filled the palace gates, the queen remained at Balmoral with her family. Under mounting public pressure and guidance from then-prime minister Tony Blair, she delivered a televised address praising Diana and acknowledging the nation's grief, calling her "an exceptional and gifted human being".
Harry's rift
More recently, Prince Harry's decision to step back from royal duties with his wife Meghan in 2020 — and their subsequent criticism of the institution in interviews, documentaries, and his memoir Spare — intensified scrutiny of the family.
Harry's lawsuits against British tabloids and his failed attempt to regain police protection further strained relations with the palace. A brief meeting between Harry and his father in September marked their first in more than a year, though it lasted less than an hour.
A monarchy under strain
Amid these ongoing tensions, Andrew's exile represents the latest test of a centuries-old institution constantly balancing tradition and accountability.
As King Charles seeks to protect the monarchy's reputation, the challenges — from historical scandals to modern controversies — continue to shape how Britons view their royal family.
